I have this bug with my Garden: As much as I want to keep all these adorable little creatures for myself, I know the Garden isn't meant to work this way. Last time I planted seeds, they were Helios Seeds. I didn't use the Watering Can on them. I don't remember how long ago they were planted. The upper-left corner is where I harvested one of the Palapees, curious to see if it would actually work. It did work, so there is currently a Frizard in my inventory. I am planning to leave my Garden alone and leave the Frizard in my inventory while you look into this bug. Let me know if there is anything else I should do, or if you have any questions.